The Ibn Khaldoun meltdown

Saad El Deen Ibrahim is finally admitting that he is on a self-imposed exile outside of Egypt, fearing his arrest by the authorities. Good. I just hoped that he would've informed the Press that the American Ambassador is the one that relayed the message to him from the egyptian authorities and urged him not to come back. But I guess he didn't want to make a big stink about the fact that the egyptian authorities treat him like an american stooge to the point of using the US ambassador- whom I can't believe agreed to this role- to inform him that they wanted him out. No Point in raising a stink. The man, after all, spent too much time in jail for his views as it is. The Problem lies in the fact that while he is abroad, his life-work is getting destroyed back here. The Ibn Khaldoun center is slowly falling apart.

Back in early 2006 I approached Dr. Ibrahim for advice on starting my own Think Thank, and the one thing he warned me against was having a one-man show there. It was right after Al Ghad Party started to fall apart with Ayman Nour going to Jail, and with the Power struggle that took place in Al Wafd Party because Nooman Gomaa wouldn't give up his seat as the party head. Dr. Ibrahim lamented to me that the problem in Egyptian leadership is that the person on top, once they arrive there, they never want to give up control or pave the way for someone to carry on their work, out of fear that those same people remove and replace them. And now we are seeing the same thing happen in  the center of Ibn Khaldoun, Dr. Ibrahim's NGO.

Dr. Ibrahim had a manager for the Center and her name was Ayyat. Ayyat , while not overly competent, knew the NGO in and out and all the contacts, and is effectively the operational manager of the center. Right after Dr. Ibrahim fled the country, the government-sponsored attack dogs newspapers showed bathing suits pictures of Ayyat and made some seriously messed up insinuations about her, which eventually led her to resign from Ibn Khaldoun. With Saad and Ayyat gone, there was no one to take charge (no institutional hierarchy to speak of exists over there), so now Dr. Ibrahim's brother is the one running the place, and doing so firmly into the ground. The man doesn't know the first thing about running an NGO, nor does he understand any of the projects there, so now the interns are the ones who are making all the decisions inside. Add to that the fact that aid for NGO's in Egypt is now simply eroding, because Egypt is now becoming a low-income country instead of a less-developed country, is not making things any easier. The Europeans have already cut most of their funding, and the USAID, I am informed, will be systematically reduced over the next 10 years until it becomes inconsequential to the overall picture. Democracy building in the middle east, after all, is no longer a priority or in fashion. The international left finally got his wish there. Good Job guys. How about a shot for every imperialistic agent of an NGO that closes its door in the next few years due to lack of funding? I am buying!

This is sad because in the world of civil society, the name Ibn Khaldoun carries with it a lot of weight, and soon it will be destroyed. No leadership, no organization and soon no funding, it won't be long till it closes down, unless the man comes back and puts his house in order. That, unfortunately, due to his belief that he would be imprisoned and killed while in prison, doesn't seem like it's going to happen anytime soon. Ibn Khaldoun may not be dead yet, but it might be wise to get out and start washing your funeral cloths. Shouldn't be long now.

0 comment on The Ibn Khaldoun meltdown

  1. John Cunningham
    October 12, 2007 at 4:23 pm

    I’m not smart enough to get into a think tank so I just sit and occassionally think about stuff. After all these years I think we’d have thought about all there is to think about. Maybe it’s time to do a little less thinking and a little more doing. That’s what I think.

  2. Candace
    October 12, 2007 at 5:32 pm

    wallahi… 🙁

  3. R.
    October 12, 2007 at 10:16 pm

    i stumbled upon ur blog and was shocked, not by ur ideas and thoughts, but by the amount of political involvement u take pleasure in..i have a few questions, if u r patient enuf to answer tham, coz i noticed u nearly never reply to someone who tries to coresspond with u. am not even sure if u do check the comments or not, but i’ll gove it a try anyways.
    how do u guys kno when there is a petition or a “mozahra” goin on someplace?
    whats the aim of these mozahrat? 3aizeen tewslo l eh menaha?
    who are alaa and manal?
    can a blog be effective enuf political wise?
    can u really be forced to close ur blog becoz some higher power discovered it?
    i’m jst an ignorant 19 yr old, would be glad i u would enlighten me.

  4. Jeff
    October 13, 2007 at 5:25 am

    Saad Eddin Ibrahim should have the Nobel Peace Prize.

  5. baraka
    October 13, 2007 at 6:51 am

    Before you hold the funeral for Ibn Khaldun Center, ya Sandmonkey, you might want to get your facts straight. Saad ibrahim had not previously been involved in the day-to-day running of the Center, even while he was in Egypt. And Ayat, the managing director, resigned several months before Dr. Saad went into exile.
    At the moment, several board members have become actively involved at the Center, and its funding is as robust as ever. And by the way, the message that he would be arrested at the airport should he return to Egypt, was conveyed by regime insiders, not the US ambassador.

    Threats to the Center will only make its staff and board more determined to carry on. And to the commentor who says he has had enough of think tanks —what got Ibn Khaldun Center in trouble was precisely its activist role –monitoring elections, training young Egyptians in how to conduct opinion polling etc.

  6. A Pigeon Called Frank
    October 13, 2007 at 5:02 pm

    I think this country puts most of its resources into monitoring and silencing outspoken people, activists and NGOs that would inevitably become a thorn in its corrupt, wrinkled ass…

    and i agree, Saad Eddin Ibrahim SHOULD get the Nobel Peace Prize.

  7. farooque el hindi
    October 14, 2007 at 12:07 am

    One is surprised that it’s taken Mr Ibrahim this long to fly the coop ala hamdi Kandeel and co. Mr Ibrahim, just like Nour, was a very flimsy stick stuck to a very big carrot, As Ms. Rice would only bring him up on an as needed basis. Nothing more nothing less, a cheap bargaining chip against JAMJOOM and BIG DADAY.

  8. the tapper
    October 14, 2007 at 3:58 am

    Sm: I’ll try again, good post….stay safe

  9. anna
    October 14, 2007 at 8:20 pm

    Back in early 2006 I approached Dr. Ibrahim for advice on starting my own Think Thank

    but you backout when the heat goes up, you kinda need staying power to actually make a difference

  10. Susan min Sa3udi
    June 12, 2008 at 3:44 pm

    poor egypt. and i say that seriously. it seems like you can’t get a freaking break.


5Pingbacks & Trackbacks on The Ibn Khaldoun meltdown

  1. […] The Sandmonkey wrote a fantastic post today on “The Ibn Khaldoun meltdown”Here’s ONLY a quick extractDemocracy building in the middle east, after all, is no longer a priority or in fashion. The international left finally got his wish there. Good Job guys. How about a shot for every imperialistic agent of an NGO that closes its door in … […]

  2. […] about at The Ibn Khaldoun meltdown – rantings of a sandmonkey, – Last Updated – 5 minutes ago    Follow This Story   Change Your […]

  3. Chapomatic says:

    […] guy. Turns out there’s an Ibn Khaldoun center in Egypt. Turns out also there have been some problems with […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *